22 美元 smoothie vs 6 元中藥奶茶
$22 smoothie vs 6-yuan herbal tea
同一個需求:喝一杯對自己好的東西
深入對照SIDE BY SIDE
| 西|Erewhon smoothie | 東|中藥奶茶 | |
|---|---|---|
| 裡面有什麼 | 杏仁奶、香蕉、草莓、酪梨、椰棗、楓糖和椰奶,再加膠原蛋白、sea moss(愛爾蘭海藻)和玻尿酸。Hailey Bieber 聯名,賣點是喝出好皮膚。 | 成都中醫藥大學的藥食同源研究團隊配方,把食材熬成湯再加牛奶。例如「暖陽」這杯,有肉桂、陳皮、黃精、黃芪和大棗。 |
| 研究怎麼說 | 膠原蛋白的證據有爭議。2025 年一份整合 23 個試驗、1,474 人的分析:全部放在一起看有效;只看沒有業者出資、或品質比較高的研究,效果就不見了。 | 這些食材能合法加進食品,是因為列在官方的「食藥物質目錄」。同一份規定也寫明:這類食品不能宣稱保健或治療功效。所以它比較像日常飲食,不是藥。 |
| 花多少 | 2022 年推出時一杯 17 美元,現在大約 20 美元上下。 | 中杯 6 元人民幣,大杯 8 元。 |
| 要小心 | 香蕉、椰棗、楓糖加椰奶,熱量和糖都不算少。當點心可以,當正餐要算一下。 | 醫師常提醒:中藥學有偏性,要看體質學,不是人人適合天天喝。懷孕或正在吃藥的人先問醫師。 |
| 在家試試 | 草莓、香蕉、酪梨、椰奶打一打,就很接近了。膠原蛋白可以省。 | 紅棗三顆、枸杞一小撮、陳皮一小片,熱水泡十分鐘,加一點熱牛奶。 |
Jasmine 說MY TAKE
價差二十幾倍(看匯率)。一個賣的是身分,一個賣的是日常。兩個我都想喝,但只有一個我會天天喝。
翻我的圖鑑FIELD GUIDES
JSLALALAND 圖鑑為什麼精品突然都在賣 wellness?|從 logo 到 routine2026 年 LA 最紅的兩杯 smoothie,都偷偷用了阿嬤的食材。相關脈案RELATED
IN ENGLISH
$22 smoothie vs 6-yuan herbal tea
Same need: a drink that's good for you
| What's inside | Almond milk, banana, strawberries, avocado, dates, maple syrup and coconut cream, plus collagen, sea moss and hyaluronic acid. A Hailey Bieber collaboration sold on skin. | Formulated by Chengdu University of TCM's food-medicine team: ingredients simmered, then mixed with milk. 'Warm Sun' has cinnamon, tangerine peel, Solomon's seal, astragalus and jujube. |
|---|---|---|
| What studies say | Collagen is contested. A 2025 meta-analysis of 23 trials and 1,474 people found benefits overall, but none when limited to trials without industry funding or to higher-quality studies. | These ingredients can go into food because they're on China's official food-medicine list. The same rules forbid ordinary foods from claiming health or treatment effects. Think daily food, not medicine. |
| What it costs | $17 at its 2022 launch; around $20 now. | 6 yuan for a medium, 8 for a large. |
| Be careful | Banana, dates, maple syrup and coconut cream add up. Fine as a treat; count it if it's a meal. | Doctors remind that herbs have their own leanings and should suit your constitution. If you're pregnant or on medication, ask first. |
| Try at home | Blend strawberries, banana, avocado and coconut cream and you're close. Skip the collagen. | Three jujubes, a pinch of goji and a small piece of tangerine peel in hot water for ten minutes, then a splash of warm milk. |
Roughly a 20x-plus price gap. One sells identity, the other sells the everyday.
出處SOURCES
- Time Out Los Angeles|Erewhon smoothies ranked (ingredients)
- Good Morning America|The $17 Strawberry Glaze Skin Smoothie (2022)
- NutraIngredients|Am J Med 2025 collagen meta-analysis and industry response
- 實況網|成都中醫藥大學 6 元中藥奶茶
- 澎湃新聞|成都中醫大附院中藥奶茶試喝
- 《按照傳統既是食品又是中藥材的物質目錄管理規定》
想拖拉滑桿、一列一列對照?打開互動版。